Old House vs New House: Which is Right for You?

It’s a question as old as time – or as old as houses. Should you buy a new home or spring for the charming old house you pass every day on your way to work? 

Whether you’re an experienced homebuyer or looking to purchase property for the first time, weighing your options can be tough. Fortunately, if you’re buying in Georgia, there are plenty of each to choose from. The state is known for its classic southern architecture and also boasts attractive new builds in great areas. 

Before you start shopping around, it’s important to understand the benefits and challenges tied to old and new homes. There’s a lot to consider, so don’t go with your gut too soon. 

To help you out, we’re breaking down the pros and cons of new and old homes and how you can find reasonable mortgage rates in Georgia when you’re ready to buy. 

get your custom mortgage rate and closing cost options

Pros of Buying an Old House

Finding an older home that suits your wants and needs can be a bit like finding a needle in a haystack, and with many baby boomers staying in their homes instead of downsizing, older homes won’t come on the market as much. 

However, buying the perfect old home is still possible, and comes with several benefits. 

Character and History

If you’re partial to a certain style and want something with timeless charm, you can’t go wrong with an old home. You’ll enjoy era-specific features like original hardwood floors, unique floor plans, crown molding, and much more. 

Basically, your entire home will be a conversation piece. Plus, you’ll enjoy a space with the character new builds can’t replicate. 

Established Neighborhoods 

Old homes are typically located in old neighborhoods. This means you’ll live in an area rich in local culture, with established schools and businesses along with mature trees and greenery. 

If this is your goal, make sure you only work with mortgage companies in Georgia that have an intimate knowledge of the local market and neighborhoods. 

Renovation and Profit Potential 

Many people buy older homes so they can renovate. If you enjoy this type of work, this is your chance to breathe life back into a house and create the space of your dreams. Renovating also adds value to the home and helps you build equity. 

Affordable Upfront Price 

You can find great deals on old homes, which can be a game-changer for your long-term financial plans. The money you save can go toward renovations or other investments. 

Cons of Buying an Old House 

While buying an old home can be fun, there are also several potential pitfalls. You’ll need to consider them closely to ensure you’re up for the challenge. 

Unexpected Costs 

Many old homes also have old appliances, HVAC units, plumbing, roofs, and foundations. This means a higher chance of sudden repairs. You’ll need to plan for the unexpected by maintaining an emergency savings account.  

Higher Energy Costs 

Unless they’ve been updated, many old homes aren’t energy efficient. Drafty windows, poor insulation, and outdated HVAC systems lead to higher utility bills. 

If you buy an old house, a smart move would be to make renovations that improve its energy efficiency. This way you’re not losing money over time. 

Hidden Problems 

With an old home, there’s a higher chance of running into unseen issues. Things like lead paint, asbestos, or structural issues aren’t always visible when you’re taking a tour. 

This is why it’s crucial to have a home inspection done. The best mortgage companies in Georgia will have connections to trusted inspectors who can help you out. 

Limited Customization 

While renovating an old home is always an option, it can be costly and time-consuming. Plus, it may be harder to get exactly what you want based on the existing floor plan. 

Pros of Buying a New House 

Buying a modern home or investing in the construction of a new build is vastly different from purchasing something older. For many people, the decision is a no-brainer for the following reasons. 


If you’re having a home built or find one that’s still early on in the construction process, you have an opportunity to tailor it to your taste. This means everything from choosing a floor plan to picking out paint colors, windows, doors, and appliances. 

Minimal Maintenance 

New homes typically include modern amenities that will last longer, cutting down on the need for repairs. You’ll have a newer air conditioner, state-of-the-art appliances, and reliable plumbing that won’t let you down.

Energy Efficiency 

Reducing your carbon footprint is much easier with a new home. Many are built using energy-efficient materials, meaning your home won’t require as much cooling and heating as old homes. 

In addition to reducing your carbon footprint, you’ll enjoy lower utility bills. This is helpful with rising energy costs

Smart Home Technology 

Modern homes are built with cutting-edge technology that would be a hassle to incorporate into an old house. These features include security systems, automated lighting, built-in internet connectivity, and energy management. 

A Good Warranty

Many home builders offer warranties that protect you if certain problems arise. You’ll have coverage for structural issues, plumbing problems, leaks, workmanship defects, and appliance breakdowns. This provides peace of mind when making such a big investment. 

If a warranty is important to you, the top mortgage companies in Georgia will have a network of connections in the real estate industry, including reliable homebuilders. 

Cons of Buying a New House

While purchasing a new home or having one built to your specs may seem like the most logical move, there are several disadvantages. 

Higher Cost 

If you plan on buying a new house, you should be prepared to pay more. New homes typically have higher sales prices due to things like construction costs, land prices, and customization. 

If buying a new home is a must for you and your family, it may be a good idea to act fast. Experts predict a rise in home prices in 2024. As one of the most transparent mortgage companies in Georgia, The Moreira Team will help you find the best interest rate possible so you can enter homeownership with confidence.   

No Room for Negotiation

If a custom-built home is on your radar, don’t expect to have much negotiation power when it comes to the price. Home builders must make a profit and rarely budge on the cost. You’ll also have to pay extra for each customization you want. 

Less Charm 

Many new homes lack the character you get with older houses. This is common in neighborhoods with homes built by the same developer. The floor plans are the same, the landscaping is bare, and the homes lack interesting features that make them one-of-a-kind. 

Young Neighborhoods

New housing developments typically don’t have an established community around them. This isn’t always a bad thing, but it’s something you need to consider. Instead of living in a neighborhood with roots, you’ll be living in an area with a future that’s uncertain. 

Work With One of The Best Mortgage Companies in Georgia 

When choosing between an old and new home, there’s no right or wrong answer. It all depends on your lifestyle and long-term goals. 

At The Moreira Team, we understand the stress that comes with buying a home. As one of the top mortgage companies in Georgia, we offer an Upfront Approval Guarantee that allows you to get approved for a loan before you start shopping around. 

Get started today and take the first step to owning the perfect home for you.